Last month, Republican
Congressional leaders filed into
the Oval Office to meet with President
George W. Bush and talk about renewing
the controversial USA Patriot Act.
Several provisions
of the act, passed in the shell
shocked period immediately following
the 9/11 terrorist attacks, caused
enough anger that liberal groups
like the American Civil Liberties
Union had joined forces with prominent
conservatives like Phyllis Schlafly
and Bob Barr to oppose renewal.
GOP leaders told
Bush that his hardcore push to renew
the more onerous provisions of the
act could further alienate conservatives
still mad at the President from
his botched attempt to nominate
White House Counsel Harriet Miers
to the Supreme Court.
“I don’t give a
goddamn,” Bush retorted. “I’m the
President and the Commander-in-Chief.
Do it my way.”
“Mr. President,”
one aide in the meeting said. “There
is a valid case that the provisions
in this law undermine the Constitution.”
“Stop throwing
the Constitution in my face,” Bush
screamed back. “It’s just a goddamned
piece of paper!”
I’ve talked to
three people present for the meeting
that day and they all confirm that
the President of the United States
called the Constitution “a goddamned
piece of paper.”
And, to the Bush
Administration, the Constitution
of the United States is little more
than toilet paper stained from all
the shit that this group of power-mad
despots have dumped on the freedoms
that “goddamned piece of paper”
used to guarantee.
Attorney General
Alberto Gonzales, while still White
House counsel, wrote that the “Constitution
is an outdated document.”
Put aside, for
a moment, political affiliation
or personal beliefs. It doesn’t
matter if you are a Democrat, Republican
or Independent. It doesn’t matter
if you support the invasion or Iraq
or not. Despite our differences,
the Constitution has stood for two
centuries as the defining document
of our government, the final source
to determine – in the end – if something
is legal or right.
Every federal official
– including the President – who
takes an oath of office swears to
“uphold and defend the Constitution
of the United States."
Supreme Court Justice
Antonin Scalia says he cringes when
someone calls the Constitution a
“living document.”
“"Oh, how
I hate the phrase we have—a 'living
document,’” Scalia says. “We now
have a Constitution that means whatever
we want it to mean. The Constitution
is not a living organism, for Pete's
sake.”
As a judge, Scalia
says, “I don't have to prove that the
Constitution is perfect; I
just have to prove that it's better
than anything else.”
President Bush
has proposed seven amendments to
the Constitution over the last five
years, including a controversial
amendment to define marriage as
a “union between a man and woman.”
Members of Congress have proposed
some 11,000 amendments over the
last decade, ranging from repeal
of the right to bear arms to a Constitutional
ban on abortion.
Scalia says the
danger of tinkering with the Constitution
comes from a loss of rights.
“We can take away
rights just as we can grant new
ones,” Scalia warns. “Don't think
that it's a one-way street.”
And don’t buy the
White House hype that the USA Patriot
Act is a necessary tool to fight
terrorism. It is a dangerous law
that infringes on the rights of
every American citizen and, as one
brave aide told President Bush,
something that undermines the Constitution
of the United States.
But why should
Bush care? After all, the Constitution
is just “a goddamned piece of paper.”